Since 2014
Put-in-Bay’s newest old bar
A reel new bar in a reel old place — remodeled for island life, kept comfortable enough to feel lived-in on the first visit.
The opening act
Andy, Ray, and the building that used to be Tony’s
In 2014, Andy Christensen and Ray Fogg opened Reel Bar on South Bass Island — home of the Village of Put-in-Bay, Ohio. The bar sits in the historic building formerly known as Tony’s, completely remodeled to honor its island roots.
As the name suggests, décor leans into fishing, boating, and Lake Erie island life. In a tongue-in-cheek play on the name: it’s a “Reel New Bar in a Reel Old Place.”
Reclaimed barn wood. Real stone. Recycled antique lighting. The original back bar still standing.
Tribute is paid to the building’s past as Tony’s with old signs, photos, and that beautiful original back bar, which has remained.
Andy’s take
Friendly staff. Exciting menu. Stage that works.
Andy says: “We have a friendly staff and an exciting food and drink menu featuring great burgers, unique sandwiches, Lake Erie fish, fresh salads, 16 draft beers and fresh squeezed cocktails. And, I’m enthusiastic about the line-up that fills our stage including island favorites like Bob Gatewood and The Ray Fogg Show. The intimacy of our stage will make performers accessible to the audience, creating a great entertainment experience.”
Inside the room
Photos from the floorboards
Edge of downtown
Next to The Old Forge. Across from Cameo. Two blocks from the bay.
Referred to as Put-in-Bay’s oldest new bar — expansive drink menu, island favorite status, and a stage that keeps people past their planned one beer.
How to get here